Monarch's Roost

Three Fire-Pit S'mores Recipes for a North Georgia Cabin Weekend

November 6, 2026

Three s’mores are worth packing for: the classic, a salted caramel and dark chocolate, and a peanut butter cup version. Monarch’s Roost has a propane fire pit ringed with Adirondack chairs, so there is no wood to haul and no smoke in your jacket. For a group of 14, plan on two to three s’mores per person, which is roughly 40 marshmallows. Here is what to bring, how to roast, and how to keep the evening easy.

What do you need for s’mores at a cabin fire pit?

Bring the supplies and your own long roasting sticks. The cabin has a propane fire pit, not a wood fire, so the flame is steady and you can hold a marshmallow above it instead of waiting for coals. For 14 people, a good shopping list is:

  • About 40 marshmallows (two or three bags)
  • Three or four boxes of graham crackers
  • Milk chocolate bars, plus dark chocolate if you want recipe two
  • A few soft caramel squares and a small shaker of flaky salt
  • A pack of peanut butter cups
  • Long roasting sticks or skewers, and a plate or two to build on

Buy the basics in town on your way up. If you are coming from Atlanta, our drive guide has ideas for where to stop.

What is the classic s’more, done well?

Break a graham cracker in half, set a square of milk chocolate on one side and hold a marshmallow above the flame, turning slowly until it is golden and soft. Slide it onto the chocolate, press the second cracker on top and wait ten seconds so the chocolate softens. The trick is patience: a slowly turned marshmallow toasts evenly and melts the chocolate, while a flaming one just chars the outside.

How do you make a salted caramel and dark chocolate s’more?

Swap the milk chocolate for a square of dark chocolate and add a soft caramel square on top of it. Build it the same way with a golden marshmallow, then finish with a tiny pinch of flaky salt before closing it. The salt cuts the sweetness, which makes this a grown-up favorite.

How do you make a peanut butter cup s’more?

Use a peanut butter cup in place of the chocolate bar, and for extra fun add a thin slice of banana underneath. Roast the marshmallow, press it on top, and close with the second cracker. It is an easy pick for kids.

How do you keep a crowd of 14 moving?

Set up a build-it station on a small table before dark, with crackers, chocolate and caramel laid out, so no one hovers over the fire pit. Let two or three people roast at a time and rotate. Adults should handle lighting and turning off the fire pit, and everyone should keep a little distance when the marshmallows are flaming. If the weather turns cold, throw on a blanket and wear gloves you do not mind getting sticky.

What should you know about the fire pit and the fireplace?

The fire pit is propane. Remove the cover, open the propane tank under the black dome, press and hold the knob to On, then press the igniter and wait a few seconds. After the evening, turn everything off and let it cool before covering it. Spare propane is by the grill. The step-by-step instructions are on our Policies and FAQ page.

S’mores are for the fire pit only. Please do not put food or s’mores in the indoor fireplace.

Good to know about bears

Bears live in this part of North Georgia. When the s’mores are done, bring leftover marshmallows, chocolate and wrappers inside, bag the trash and place it in the bear-proof enclosure by the driveway, securing the bear straps. Never leave food outside and keep a safe distance from any wildlife you see. You will likely see deer in the front yard at dusk, which is half of the fun.

Where do you pair s’mores with the rest of the weekend?

Fire pit nights fit nicely after a day on the trail or a long afternoon in the game room. If you are planning a cold-weather weekend, our guide to a cabin with a hot tub and sauna near Helen in winter has ideas for the rest of the day. For a bigger celebration, the family reunion guide shows how to plan meals and sleeping for the whole group.

Ready for a fire pit weekend?

Check availability and book direct.

Sources

All fire pit, fireplace and wildlife guidance comes from the Monarch’s Roost policies page and the owner’s house instructions. Recipes are standard home-cooking techniques, not attributed to any outside source.


Planning a group trip? Check dates and book direct at Monarch's Roost.

Ask about the Roost